Can a California Prenup Keep the Court Out?
Understanding the Limits of Court Intervention
One common question that our clients frequently ask is whether we can draft a prenup with provisions to prevent the courts from ever getting involved in the event of a dispute. The short answer is no. Under California law, you generally cannot draft a prenuptial agreement that completely prevents a court from intervening in marital or family law disputes—especially in areas such as child support, child custody, and (in many cases) spousal support. The court always retains oversight to ensure that any provisions are fair and do not violate public policy.
Why the Court Retains Jurisdiction
California’s Family Code—and, more broadly, California public policy—protects certain rights that cannot be waived. The courts maintain jurisdiction to review issues that might affect the well-being of spouses and children, as well as to ensure any contractual terms aren’t unconscionable or contrary to public policy.
Best Interests of the Child
A critical area where courts will always step in is child support and custody. California (like all states) treats the welfare of children as paramount. Parents cannot waive or contract away a child’s right to support or the court’s authority to determine custody based on the child’s best interests. No agreement can override a child’s right to financial support or prevent a judge from making a custody determination based on the child’s best interests. Thus, you cannot waive child support obligations, nor can you dictate custody arrangements that bypass a court’s power to review. Any clause that attempts to bar the court from intervening in child-related matters or eliminate the court review of these matters will be deemed unenforceable.
Spousal Support
While parties can address spousal support in a prenuptial agreement, California Family Code sets strict rules. If a spousal support waiver (or limitation) is unconscionable at the time of enforcement, or if one party did not execute the agreement voluntarily or with adequate knowledge, it can be invalidated. Thus, a prenup can address spousal support, but it must be reasonable and executed properly. Even if the agreement attempts to remove the court from deciding spousal support, courts retain the power to review these provisions to ensure they are not unconscionable at the time of enforcement. Thus, the court can overrule spousal support provisions in your prenup if it deems them grossly unreasonable at the time of divorce, regardless if it was reasonable or conscionable when the agreement was executed.
Arbitration and Mediation Clauses
Parties can agree to arbitrate or mediate certain property or financial disputes to avoid litigation. However, this does not remove the court’s fundamental oversight. If a dispute arises or if there’s a need to enforce or vacate an arbitration award, the parties inevitably may need to go to court. Therefore, while you may include an arbitration or mediation clause for property division or spousal support disputes to attempt to avoid court, but if the agreement is challenged, a court can still intervene to determine enforceability. The court retains the ultimate authority.
The bottom line is that when it comes to California prenuptial agreements, you can shape a lot of your financial future with your spouse, but you can’t completely shut the court’s door and completely bar the court from intervening in marital and family law disputes under California law. While you may include terms to handle property division and spousal support (subject to fairness and disclosure requirements), provisions that purport to eliminate all court oversight—particularly in child-related matters—are unenforceable as a matter of public policy. Any attempt to restrict court review of child-related matters is off-limits and will be stricken if challenged. Mediation or arbitration clauses can be included, but they don’t prevent the court from reviewing or enforcing the outcome.
A well-drafted prenuptial agreement offers clarity, reduces conflict, and protects both spouses’ interests. However, crafting a valid agreement that meets California’s strict legal requirements can be complex. Always consult with an experienced family law attorney before drafting or signing any prenuptial agreement to ensure that its provisions are valid and will hold up in court. The best path is to work with a knowledgeable attorney who can guide you in drafting a prenuptial agreement that’s both comprehensive and enforceable.
If you have questions or are considering a prenuptial agreement, we are here to help. We understand the nuances of California family law and can help you craft an agreement that protects your interests and complies with all legal requirements. Contact us today to schedule a free consultation.
Get Free Consultation
All content provided on this blog is for informational purposes only. We will not be liable for any errors or omissions in this information nor for the availability of this information. These terms and conditions of use are subject to change at any time and without notice. The information provided here and the content on our website related to legal matters (“Information”) is provided for your private use and does not constitute legal advice. You should consult a licensed attorney if you need legal advice for a specific problem. The information provided here is not a substitute for legal advice from a qualified attorney licensed to practice in an appropriate jurisdiction.